Experiments in galbi


P1010373It was Sunday evening.  I had four short ribs, big meaty things.  About 2.5 pounds worth after I trimmed most of the fat.  I also had a lot of questions.

Does Coke belong in galbi?  Would kiwi really make a difference in tenderizing short ribs?  Was it the pureed onion and apple that had made my galbi taste slightly muddy the other night?  Or was it the thickness of the cut?

This August, I’d taken advantage of my friends with backyards and grilled galbi, Korean marinated short ribs.  Both times I’d been underwhelmed.   The first time, there was clearly not enough soy sauce.  The second time, the batch I’d bathed in Coca-Cola was tastier than the batch I hadn’t, but I wasn’t sure if it had to do with the marinade or the quality of the beef or even how thinly it had been cut, since the two batches of ribs came from different sources.

The weather had finally cooled down and I felt energized, rejuvenated.  These were questions that had to be answered and soon, while the taste of Saturday night’s ribs could still be remembered.

The basics:

Galbi or 갈비 is the Korean word for beef short rib, one of the most beloved cuts of meat in Korean cuisine.  “Galbi-gui” means grilled short rib, and even though Koreans love to grill all kinds of things, “galbi” has become synonymous with “Korean barbecue” around the world.

Galbi is often eaten plain and without marinade.  Even though it can be a tough cut of meat, Koreans highly value chewiness, and those who really love meat know, like all meat-lovers around the world, that the best way to eat the best meat is unadorned.

But when people say “galbi,” they normally mean the marinated version.  Short ribs are marinated for up to 24 hours in a mix of soy sauce, sweeteners, sesame oil, garlic and green onion that both tenderize and flavor the meat.  Galbi can be broiled in the oven, but grilling, especially over charcoal, brings out the best flavor.  The fat drips off the meat, the sugars in the marinade caramelize, and you end up with some of the best summer barbecue eating in the world.

The classic, original cut is a butterflied short rib, where the big hunk of meat attached to the bone is cut and rolled out until you’re left with a thin, long strip of beef attached to the rib.  This is what you’ll usually find in Korean restaurants, both in Korea and in the U.S.  The cut that Koreans have adopted as their own for home cooking, though, and increasingly easy to find is flanken or “LA style,” presumably because Korean immigrants in LA found this cut more readily than what they’d had at home.  In this cut, the ribs, which are still attached together, are cut cross-wise, so that each thin slice of meat has three bones attached.  This cut doesn’t require any extra work for the home cook, and they’re very easy to lay on the grill and flip.   Korean groceries will often also sell boneless short ribs, which is the worst kind of oxymoron.

The marinade has infinite variations, which isn’t surprising, given that galbi is for Koreans what the hamburger is for Americans.  But there are some fundamental principles.  There is always soy sauce, sesame oil, and plenty of chopped garlic and green onion.  There is always a sweetener, whether it’s sugar, honey, mirin (rice wine), and even Coke and Sprite.  Acidic ingredients like pureed Asian pear, apple or kiwi are also popular for tenderizing the meat, though I’ve had more than one Korean mom tell me, “Oh God, it was horrible!  I put in too much and the meat turned to mush!”

The exact proportions are a matter of taste.  And this is where my questions lay.

The experiment:

In all the recipes I saw, the variations seemed to be in what was added to the soy sauce, sesame oil, garlic, green onion and sugar.  One cook extolled the clean, neat flavor of adding nothing more.  Others added everything, honey, pear, onion, mirin, Coke, and kiwi.

I wanted to know how each of these ingredients, in and of themselves, affected the flavor.  So I started with a base sauce:

  • ¾ cup Korean dark soy sauce
  • 2 T. sugar
  • ½ cup green onion
  • 2 T. minced garlic
  • 2 T. sesame oil
  • 1 T. sesame seed
  • and a couple of grinds of black pepper

I had used LA-style ribs for my cookouts, but for this experiment, I was too lazy to bike to the butcher, so I picked up some regular meaty short ribs at my coop and decided to butterfly them myself.  Not so pretty, but good enough.


Each rib was then assigned one marinade and placed in a labeled Ziploc bag.

Rib 1 got just a quarter of the base sauce.

Rib 2 got a quarter of the base sauce plus:

  • 2 tablespoons of mirin or rice wine
  • ¼ Fuji apple pureed and strained for the juice
  • ¼ white onion pureed and strained for the juice

(I didn’t have time to go to Koreatown for an Asian pear, and I was more curious if straining the puree would make a difference.)

Rib 3 got a quarter of the base sauce plus ¼ cup of Coca-Cola Classic.

Finally, Rib 4 got a quarter of the base sauce plus ¼ cup of Coke and a teaspoon of pureed kiwi.  Putting in that bit of kiwi was almost terrifying—what would I find the next morning?

The results:

From left to right, Rib 1 to Rib 4.

From left to right, Rib 1 to Rib 4.

I let the four little baggies marinate in the fridge overnight.  The next day, I broiled them all at once, 5 minutes on each side.  I also roasted the rib bones separately in a 400 degree oven for 25 minutes, flipping them halfway.  I wasn’t going to waste all that delicious fat, tendon, and gristle!

But the most important part, of course, is which rib won.


Rib 2!

At least it was for me.  If I’d had more forethought, I would have invited my other friends who work from home for lunch.  The only other taste tester was Ursa the Dog, and she doesn’t know how to talk.

Still, I’m pretty confident in my winner.  The muddy flavor that I’d found when I’d just thrown in the fruit/onion puree was completely gone.  Instead, there was a mellow sweetness, a smooth but light flavor that went very well when wrapped in a piece of crisp lettuce with my spicy bean-paste ssamjang and a bit of rice.

Rib 3, which had coke added to it, was my second-favorite.  It was tasty, though it just didn’t taste as balanced as Rib 2.  I’m still curious to know how galbi would taste if coke were added to the mixture in Rib 2.  I’m feeling much more open-minded to High Fructose Corn Syrup Flavored Soda Made by The Man in my galbi marinade than I used to be.

Rib 4 was a tad tenderer than the other ribs, which I’ll attribute to the kiwi.  But the acidity cancelled out the sweetness of the soda and sugar, making the soy sauce flavor much stronger.  If you do want to add kiwi, I would add another tablespoon of sugar.  I also didn’t think the kiwi made it so much more tender that it was crucial, but I am a girl who really likes her meat to have some chew.

Rib 1 was my least favorite.  The soy sauce flavor was much too strong and it was all I could taste.

But to be completely honest, there wasn’t a huge difference between each rib.  I consider this good news—it means anyone can make galbi, whether they have access to Asian pears or kiwis.  (I’m sure there are very few people left on the planet who do not have access to Coke.)

There was, however, a noticeable difference in flavor between these four ribs and the ribs I’d made for my friends.  The first dinner, I’d used pre-cut LA-style ribs from Assi Plaza in Flushing.  The second dinner, I went to Los Paisanos in Cobble Hill and got good quality “all-natural” meat, for what it’s worth, that they cut to my specifications into LA-style ribs, as well as some ribs from a Korean store of unknown quality.

For this experiment, though, I used grass-fed beef from McDonald, a New York State beef supplier for the Park Slope Food Coop.

I love gristle and tendon so much.

I love gristle and tendon so much.

I’m not one of those people who think everything labeled “grass-fed” tastes better and sends you to heaven at the same time.  It’s possible that the cut, despite my clumsy butterflying job, was more critical in affecting the flavor.  It just gives you more to chew than the thin LA-style.  Regardless, my broiler-batch at home definitely tasted better than the galbi I’d grilled at Mimi and Alex’s and at Ryan and Ellen’s.  I’m sorry, friends, that you weren’t at home with me to taste these ribs!


Phew, long post!  Despite my pontificating, I’m still not really sure what makes the best galbi.  But next time, I think I will buy meaty ribs, butterfly them myself, trim the fat a bit more closely, and then marinate them in a mixture of pureed and strained Asian pear/onion and mirin, along with the soy sauce, sugar, garlic, green onion, sesame oil and sesame seeds.  If the quality of the meat is a bit off, I will likely add another tablespoon of sugar.  In general, I’ve found that the marinade at the outset has to be slightly sweeter than you want the finished product to be.  All the marinades were noticeably sweet; none of the ribs were cloyingly so.  So if you like sweeter galbi, you definitely have to add more sugar/coke/what have you than I did.

And in case you’re wondering, I did not eat all two-and-a-half pounds of ribs for lunch.  I had a nice lunch and the dog ate a bit, though not too much as her owner had exhorted me not to let her get fat while he was gone. The leftovers went in the fridge.  Don’t feel too sorry for her, though.  She’s sleeping as I type and smacking her lips as she dreams.

I took the bone away when I realized it could splinter, but she enjoyed it for awhile.

I took the bone away when I realized it could splinter, but she enjoyed it for awhile.


9 Responses to “Experiments in galbi”

  1. erin Says:

    this reads like an episode of america’s test kitchens, but 100% more interesting. plus cute dog pictures to boot. i love it!

  2. Dave Says:

    Great write up! Why couldn’t high school chemistry be more like this?

    I’ve been experimenting myself trying to figure out which marinade I like the best. Recently I used my aunt’s recipe which uses red wine instead of rice wine. The problem though is that I never make different versions of the marinade for the same meal and it’s hard to compare things over that much time.

    I’m going to try some for a BBQ this weekend though although I couldn’t get any beef ribs from any of the local butchers! I’m going to try skirt steak instead and make some sort of beefy bulgogi steak sandwiches.

  3. Grace Says:

    Thanks! Ha ha, I love the idea of high school chemistry being around food. We could all have learned a lot about the properties of sugar, soy sauce, etc.

    Even if you can’t compare how the red wine works, what do you like about that recipe? I’m starting to hear about that more, too, people using red wine and I’m so curious. How much do you add?

  4. Dave Says:

    I suppose I’d say it tasted richer? Deeper? Here’s the recipe that my aunt told me, which I’ve mostly forgotten and need to clarify with her again.

    1 cup soy sauce
    1 cup red wine
    1 cup pureed onion
    1/2 cup sugar
    a few cloves of garlic

    So that’s my hazy starting point. I removed some of the sugar and added a pureed pear. I’m sure she must have included some seasame oil so I added about a quarter cup.

    I’ll try to be a bit more ‘scientific’ this time around.

  5. Grace Says:

    Thanks so much! Your aunt’s version seems like what would happen if galbi and beef bourguignon had a baby 🙂 Will definitely have to try this sometime soon. I wonder how the same marinade would affect galbi-jjim?

    It is really hard to compare different recipes. Kind of makes me want to have a galbi festival, where every person brings a different recipe, and we taste all of them at once.

  6. Leslie Says:

    Great post! By the way, we used to give Daisy kalbi bones now and then. She would growl really loud when we went near her and would eat every last piece of it.

  7. Rita Says:

    Such a game trying to get the recipe just right! I just tried the soy sauce, 7-up version with tremendous reluctance, but it was quite good. I do use tons of ginger and garlic. Today a woman at my local korean supermarket advised that the korean pear is a must…but no more than 1/2 a pear for 600 grams of meat or it can go to mush. She also suggested using mirin or sake. If you’re using a tender cut of meat like skirt steak, you problably don’t need to worry about the tenderizing ingredients. If you’re using them for flavour then don’t marinate in excess of 24 hours. Good luck! 🙂

  8. Grace Says:

    Rita, how much 7-up did you use in proportion to the soy sauce? I am inclined to think of Asian pear as a must also, and her proportions seem similar to mine.

  9. mamabatesmotel Says:

    Reblogged this on mamabatesmotel.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: